If you’re thinking about selling your home, one of the biggest decisions you’ll make is how to hire a listing agent.
Most homeowners choose a REALTOR® one of two ways: they hire a friend’s recommendation, or they click on the first agent they find online. The problem is that choosing the wrong agent can literally cost you tens of thousands of dollars depending on how your home is priced, marketed, and negotiated.
The reality is that not all agents approach real estate the same way. Some simply list homes. Others focus on strategy, marketing, and negotiation to help sellers get the strongest possible outcome.
If you’re trying to figure out how to choose a listing agent, these twelve factors will help you confidently decide who should represent you when selling your home.
1. Is the REALTOR® Full-Time or Part-Time?
One of the first things to consider when hiring a listing agent is whether real estate is their full-time profession. Real estate moves quickly. Offers can arrive late at night. Negotiations happen on weekends. Inspection issues sometimes require immediate attention. A full-time agent is constantly watching the market, negotiating contracts, and managing transactions. That daily experience often makes a major difference when it comes to pricing strategy, communication, and problem-solving.
2. Do They Understand the Local Market?
Another key factor when deciding how to choose a REALTOR® to sell your home is their understanding of the local market. Real estate isn’t one big market. It’s a collection of micro-markets. Different neighborhoods can have completely different buyer demand, pricing trends, and selling timelines.Agents who understand these micro-markets know how to position your home so it stands out to buyers.
3. Do You Feel Comfortable Communicating With Them?
Selling a home involves a lot of conversations:
• pricing discussions
• repair negotiations
• inspection issues
• offer strategies
The right listing agent should make you feel comfortable asking questions. They should explain things clearly and communicate openly throughout the process. Good communication is one of the most overlooked qualities when sellers are learning how to hire a listing agent.
4. Look at Their Online Reviews (But Dig Deeper)
Online reviews can be helpful when researching how to find a good REALTOR® but it’s important to look beyond the star rating. Some agents advertise hundreds of reviews because they are part of a large team. Those reviews may not reflect the experience you’ll have with the individual agent you’re hiring. Try to determine whether the feedback specifically refers to the agent you will be working with.
5. Understand How Agents Appear Online
If you’ve searched for a REALTOR® online, you’ve probably seen the phrase “featured agent.” In many cases, these placements are paid advertising. While that doesn’t mean the agent is inexperienced, it does mean that online visibility doesn’t always equal expertise. When hiring a listing agent, focus more on their strategy and results than their advertising placement.
6. Ask About Their Marketing Plan
Marketing plays a huge role in how successfully a home sells.
Putting a property in the MLS is just the beginning. A strong listing strategy often includes:
• professional photography
• a launch strategy
• social media exposure
• targeted buyer visibility
When marketing is done well, more buyers see the property. More eyes from buyers typically leads to stronger offers.
7. Consider Their Social Media Presence
Today’s buyers often discover homes through social media platforms.
Agents who actively market listings online can generate significant exposure for a property quickly. Their audience may already be engaged with their content, which can help create early interest when your home hits the market. When learning how to choose a listing agent, this modern marketing channel is becoming increasingly important.
8. Review Their Sales Performance
An agent’s past performance can reveal a lot about their ability to price and negotiate effectively.
When interviewing agents, ask questions like:
• How quickly do your listings typically sell?
• How close do they sell to the asking price?
These numbers help you understand whether the agent consistently achieves strong outcomes for sellers.
9. Do They Track Listing Analytics?
Today’s real estate market provides a lot of useful data.
Agents can track things like:
• online listing views
• showing activity
• buyer engagement
Agents who analyze these metrics can adjust strategy if needed to keep a listing performing well.
10. Research the Agent Online
Before choosing a REALTOR® search for them online the same way a buyer might.
Look at their website, social media presence, and professional profiles. A strong online presence builds credibility and can also influence how other agents and buyers perceive the listing.
11. Schedule a Real Listing Consultation
A professional listing consultation should be more than just signing paperwork.
A good agent will walk through your home, discuss pricing strategy, recommend improvements that could increase value, and develop a plan for how the property will be launched on the market. This conversation is an important step in hiring a real estate agent to sell your house.
Experienced listing agents typically have trusted professionals they can recommend. The best agents will provide multiple options and encourage you to research them independently.
The Bottom Line
Learning how to hire a listing agent is one of the most important steps in selling a home.
The right REALTOR® doesn’t just list your property. They guide pricing strategy, manage negotiations, communicate clearly, and help navigate the entire process from listing to closing.
By looking into these 12 things, you’ll quickly be able to tell the difference between an agent who simply puts homes on the market versus an agent who knows what they’re doing. You’ll also discern one who truly understands how to sell them.
Selling a Home in Berea or Richmond, Kentucky?
If you’re selling a home in Berea, Richmond, or anywhere in Madison County, choosing the right listing agent can make a major difference in your final sale price and overall experience.
If you’d like to talk through your options or ask questions about selling your home, feel free to reach out.
Devin – the best realtor ever! Seriously! She had so many deals going on while she was selling our place and helping us find our new home but her constant hustle is unmatched. She had our house under contract in 3 days and helped us fairly negotiate the purchase/repairs of our new home. Even though she had several other deals/clients, we always felt like we were her only clients when she spoke with us. Also – you will not meet another realtor who is so willing to roll up her sleeves and jump into help wherever needed!
I found Devin’s greatest strengths to be pricing a home right, marketing skills, fair negotiations, and knowledge of the current market. Her personality and desire to be helpful is just a bonus. If I’m being honest I knew who Devin was before reaching out to her – but it truly feels like she has become a part of our family during this whole process. We will definitely use her for any real estate needs in the future and we highly recommend you do too!
Devin has been an amazing agent to do business with! I’ve provided home listing media to her for several homes and she always ensures excellent marketing for her sellers!
She goes above and beyond for her clients, from photo prep work, to creative marketing, ✨📸nothing is left to chance!
In addition she’s very active in her community serving in many different roles and somehow balances it all! Highly recommend:)
Let me tell you about Devin Ramsey – Madison County’s secret weapon!
I’ve had the privilege of being in a coaching group with Devin, and I can tell you, she operates at a level most agents aspire to reach.
Being in coaching with her has been incredible to watch and inspiring! While other agents talk about client service, Devin DELIVERS it on a whole new level!
Devin is highly knowledgeable and takes the time to explain things clearly. She shows great patience and is also an excellent negotiator. It’s easy to see why clients love her so much! She’s the queen of Real Estate in Berea, KY.
Devin sold our home in such short time and made the search for our new home as easy as one could ask for. She showed us 10+ houses a day and worked for us all hours of the day even weekends. Can’t recommend enough. Thank you Devin!
Response from the owner 15:26 11 Sep 25
Helping you sell your home & find your new one in Madison County, KY was an absolute honor. Thank you for choosing me as your real estate agent!
Devin is a dream to work with! Anytime I needed anything she was on top of it, no matter what time. My situation was a rough closing but she kept me calm and was on top of it all! I can’t recommend her enough!
Response from the owner 15:27 11 Sep 25
When I say “we got this” I sure mean it! I’m so grateful you trusted me with both your sale in Richmond, KY & your purchase here in Berea, KY — it’s clients like you who make me love being a realtor!
Working with Devin was an amazing experience. As first-time homebuyers, we had a lot of questions, and she was incredibly patient, kind, and thorough every step of the way. Devin explained every detail clearly, helped us understand the entire process, and always made sure we felt informed and confident. Her honesty and guidance were invaluable—she truly had our family’s best interests at heart. We highly recommend her to anyone, especially first-time buyers!
Response from the owner 15:28 11 Sep 25
Stop it! You all are the absolute best. Helping first-time homebuyers like you is why I love what I do. Thank you for choosing me as your Richmond, KY realtor — I’m so happy we found the perfect first home for your growing family!
I was recommended to Devin by the best loan officer in the business Kyle Best. Devin is Joanie-on-the-spot on everything!! We looked at multiple houses on many days and she was always there ready to help us find our dream home and answered soooo many questions we had as a first time home buyer. We saw some great houses and some that only looked great online and she never got discouraged after we turned many houses down almost immediately. She kept us motivated to keep looking and after 1 failed offer and many houses we finally found the one! The entire process from start to finish took slightly over a month.
Best realtor in the business!! Definitely in the area lol! Thank you Devin! We are forever grateful for your time and advice.
Response from the owner 15:28 11 Sep 25
It means the world that you trusted me with such an important milestone. I’m grateful to be your Berea, KY real estate agent — congratulations on your first home!
Devyn is amazing! So patient with me and my first time home buying experience. Always there to address my questions and concerns day and night and walk me through the process step by step without expressing any kind of frustration or aggravation and so friendly and easy to chat with! 10/10 recommend!
Response from the owner 15:29 11 Sep 25
Appreciate you so much Jamie!It was an honor helping you buy your new home in Richmond, KY. I’m so grateful you chose me as your local real estate agent.
Throughout our buying and selling journey, Devin has been incredibly patient, responsive, and supportive every step of the way. She went above and beyond for our family—during showings, she would even play with our two-year-old so we could truly focus on the home. Her knowledge of both real estate and Madison County is unmatched, and it made all the difference for us. We’re so grateful for Devin’s guidance, care, and expertise over the past three months!
Response from the owner 15:30 11 Sep 25
I cannot thank you enough for this! Helping you sell your home in Berea, KY and find your new one here in Madison County, KY was an absolute honor Kayla! Thank you for choosing me as your listing agent & buying agent!
I had such a wonderful experience. I would recommend her to everyone I know! It was such a smooth process from start to finish. Go with her, you won’t be disappointed!!!!
We met in a network of female realtors, and I must say, she is a true gem! Honest, dedicated, and professional. Her engagements with other agents shows her dedication to team work.
Devin was great to work with while searching for my home. Every question that I had she answered very quick, even late at night took my phone calls. Would highly recommend Devin to anyone.
I have waited till the perfect time to write this review. DEVIN has absolutely made my year! She pushed harder than any person I know along with my mortgage company just to make my dreams come true! She went above and beyond and made sure all my babies could be together in our new home for christmas. This is the first of many Christmas in our new home. Thank you Devin for being you. You strive to make each customer feel special, you accommodate and look for things about each one of us to make each sale their very own. I woukd 10/10 recommend her to anyone!!!!
She got ‘em and my family in a home within a month and no down payment! She is such a sweet loving woman! She has such a bubbly and outgoing personality! Amazing work!❤️
Devin is by far the most patient and helpful person. She helped, added he suggestions and made sure we were happy. Never pressured us or rush in in any way. I’m sure we were annoying at times. From distant, day long trips looking or arranging us to see future homes with other associates. Devin always delivered! Dealing with roads curvy enough to make a child nauseous, we always had a good time with Devin! I can’t say thank you enough. For anyone in the market to sell or purchase, Devin is the girl to get you on your way.
Me and my wife were 100% satisfied with Devin. She ever had a repair done on the house that was not her responsibility at all but she felt bad because the seller didn’t do it like he was supposed too. She did everything she could to make sure that we were happy with our new house.
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.